ATB Im genuinely interested, because I always want to make sure that my beliefs are in line with scripture. People of my faith dont abrogate obeying their consciences when they are in a position where authority is present quite the opposite. To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Egalitarianism hurts the sheep. The current disagreements over womens ordination are similar in saying that while scripture does not specifically permit that role for women even so to deny it to women violates some other values which are found in scripture. We also have in my Church a special name for the woman who was sent to announce the Resurrection to the Apostles: Mary Magdalene is known in my Church as the Apostle to the Apostles. To this day, my husband and I continue to support them in their ministry even though they are still complementarian because theyget it. It was this man and his wife. I did not make this up; check it out on line. So Pete helps people sort through these conflicts and feelings and plan for the future. You are talking about a huge number affected by all of this teaching, and to so restrict that group because somehow (for no reason I have really seen, what have I to do with a man who wants to be transsexual??? He believes that only men can be pastors. If we threw them out, how would they hear Gods Word and witness and experience Gods transforming love? Everything from wonderful women teachers in Bible Study Fellowship, wearing a hat from the pulpit because the church where it was being held required a woman to have her head covered (Remember when the ladies wore hats to church and the Catholic women always carried a scarf in their purse). You are spot on. 1K views, 37 likes, 6 loves, 1 comments, 8 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from Bent Tree Bible: "Bent Tree exists to be used by God as he transforms people into disciples of Jesus Christ here and. Yet it would also be wrong to say that priests, in terms of authority, are equal to the laity. I do not see very many benefits belonging to a SBC association, a state SBC convention or the the national SBC. . It was the associations loss, IMO. The Word was made for men and women, not men and women for the Word. The church is nondenominational and has woman pastors and elders. +(503)71037139 [email protected] Login. The elders continued to meet with the errant husband, begging him to reconsider what he was doing. 2. "One of the things I learned a number of years ago is that grace is doing the most loving thing," he said. What transpired at that meeting still brings tears to my eyes. I believe in naming the specific sin (such as adultery) without giving specific details (such as with who if the other party is not on staff or how).". If all sides are committed to the authority of scripture, then perhaps we have some common ground upon which to persuade one another. Will we obey God or not? After confronting the two, Powell disclosed the information to the congregation. That makes it hard sometimes for me to understand your views of complimentarian roles, and I am grateful for your comment, as it helps give some insight into the differences and the similarities that exist and must be recognized and respected by those of my faith as something meaningful to you. You wrote, To be honest, the description of complementarian in the conservative evangelical world is not at all recognizable to me, The difficulty is that even feminists acknowledge some sort of complementarity between the sexes. The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user. At the end of the day, a church will either ordain women pastors or they wont. I explain that a public leader's failure deserves a public explanation. Whu? BTW, Kirk Cameron is apparently giving more interviews about marriage again. . May Bent Tree Bible Fellowship be greatly blessed as you continue to carry out the Great Commission using ALL of the gifts God has bestowed upon the local church body. Although I disagree with them, I hope and pray the best for Bent Tree. Briscoe and the elders say that they intend to be a conservative church that maintains a tenacious commitment to the Inerrancy of scripture. This is not easy. In the ensuing years, I was involved in watching another church handle a conflict in such a poor manner that I felt I had entered the Twilight Zone. I also saw a quote from living spirituality on fb, (from LAbri guy Greg Loughery) about how the evangelical church has no time for uncertainty (or agreeing to disagree, my paraphrase) but overlooking arrogance with ease. Pete grew up in a home withintelligent andcommitted parents: both dad and mom. There is one on Sanibel. these people remain, and their lot is patience and long-suffering, and hope for better days . Still, whether they realize this or not, the theological rationale for their decision is at odds with a commitment to the Bibles authority. Yes!!! This is an absolutely joyous article. Which is part of why I am currently attending a much more liberal church than I would otherwise be inclined to attend. The Dyers knew his parents, Stuart and Jill Briscoe from Elmbrook Church in Wisconsin, who had spoken at Willow on several occasions. This surprises me is it true? To know there is a theologically conservative church with a deeply rooted all-male elder board who changed their minds after sincerely searching Gods word, is a great encouragement to me, as my own elder board has not even considered doing so. Here it is with one update. So yes, you will see the the marketing behind the issue change. I mean, if these men truly see themselves as depraved, then they could not honestly claim to be able to be ethically and morally suitable to step in and take over the place of the Holy Spirit in the lives of women of Christian conscience. really powerful comment! Bent Tree Bible in Carrollton has flirted with this issue for years, but now they feel safe to publically embrace it. I asked one of the women why they didnt let women speak and she said because women are so easily deceived and the start of so many cults and I replied yes, like Jim Jones, J. Smith, Armstrong, Scientology, etc etc etc. When we feel beyond God's redemption, Jesus has good news for us. Similarly, male headship is not normative in the Bible look at Miriam, Deborah, Ruth, Esther, Huldah, for example. No big deal. that tells me he is open to diversity in the whole Church as something to be celebrated rather than excluded. Now the shoe is on the other foot in at least one church. But I live a couple of hours from there. I am not going to give a point-by-point rebuttal. The laity may not perform the Mass. Pete Briscoe and elders, this encourages me to renew prayers for my elders to have hearts to seek the Lord as He leads them by His time and in His plans. Therefore, love for God, the gospel, and future generations, demands the careful presentation and pressing of the complementarian position. After giving a lecture outlining CBEs position, one Sydney theologian told me publicly, You reject what Scripture plainly teaches. And, in fact, which basically split the church in recent years; I mean an actual organic split ending in court over the properties. Sopy Bent Tree Bible Message from Sunday, 14 December 2014 Title: Part 8: Jesus, Better Than Striving Series: Better - A New and Living Way (Hebrews. Your first point draws on a quote from Ligon Duncan, a Presbyterian, which I felt was rather curious. 1 Timothy 2:12 But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence. He is a truly humble man. But that does not negate the very real concern about the hermeneutical principles that they have embraced. I listened to his talk in full and made notes. The exact meaning of the Scriptures is essentially unchanged in any important respect in the widely accepted English translations. 5:18; 1 Cor. Some day in the distant future Dee will read email from me BEFORE reading the blog comments. are they seen as dichotomous totally? Denny, thanks for sharing. I live in Elverson. What were the situations that were understood, the things in the local culture that the people who received Pauls letter all knew about and did not need to be spelled out? As Scott McKnight recently commented, there is absolutely no consensus about 1 Tim 2, so your suggestion that this is clear has no foundation. I incorporated it into todays post: Being Egalitarian and Taking the Bible Seriously. For example, whilst God does reveal himself as father, you forget that he also reveals himself as mother (Isaiah 49:15 and many more). The Beatles performed under various names and with different line-ups before they settked into their identity.The original drummer Pete Best, however, was replaced by Sir Ringo Starr before the . However, we are to believe that Paul, led by the Holy Spirit, instituted such female prohibitions in the New Covenant where Jesus did not. Otherwise, rumors will inevitably spread, say pastors who have gone through the experience. I agree about lines in the sand for clarity sake. You make reference to the teachings of your Church, with regard to complementarian roles as mutual service to one another out of love, not because of the authority of one person over another subordinate. I understand your Church to be the Roman Church. We are in South Arlington, and I wish there was a BT campus close by! Before that it was a focus on what is feminine. It will come as no surprise to you that I concur with Pete Briscoes stance on elders as well as pastors. Ben, my own Church understands complementarian roles as mutual service to one another out of love, not because of the authority of one person over another subordinate. This is heartbreaking and painful to watch. They tack on a lot of unrelated things to the bill and so if another Congress person is against that then they are positioned as wanting children to starve or hate refugees or something. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. It is God Who gives life to all living. If you are unfamiliar with this, here it is in a nutshell. One of the saddest anecdotes from the Jim Jones thing was that when they started killing the children, his wife (I think) fought it and was held back (by men!) Maybe is good; must is bad. It is with heavy hearts that the Elders of Bent Tree announce that Pete Briscoe has submitted his resignation as Senior Pastor. Yet, her intelligence was tempered by her devastating wit. Add to this that most people love the self-help industry and rules, roles and formulas for living life. When your community revolves around the church, you are losing quite a bit to leave. Our views are grounded in scripture, as complementarianism is not a valid reading of the Bible. He put his arm around her during worship time and then went up to preach. I hold the church would have failed miserably without women, it actually would not exist. They too appealed to the Bible with enormous confidence, claiming that it unambiguously supported slavery and Apartheid. Here still we shall stand. You dont believe women should be prevented from all church roles but the nursery = you dont believe in the bible. 5:18; 2 Tim. Thank you, Dee. I wonder if theyd consider doing so? If women, then why not LGBTQ people? It is no lack of charity, nor honesty. I meant to say that YRR pastors signed their churches up for the Secret Church Simulcast. Dont ever let anyone tell you that you cant teach. And I have not. There we go, much better. What light can pastor Briscoe shed as well? Briscoe and the elders do not wish to do that. . For some reason, it seems to be the only site on the internet that I can not get into. Hope youll give us another try and check out some other articles. Our condemnation is in our father Adam, who sinned against God in the garden, and our salvation is in Jesus Christ, the God-Man or New Adam. This man was so overwhelmed by the constant contact of the elders and decided that he was wrong. Pete briscoe was senior pastor of bent tree bible fellowship in carrollton, tx for nearly 30 years. Last night I watched Pastor Pete Briscoe give his rationale for leading his church to welcome female elders to their leadership structure (see above). Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone by making a one-time donation today. The thinking goes like this: the first proposed Civil Rights Act gave more freedom and equality to black women than white women had in some areas. Eve sinned because Adam didnt properly teach her Gods ways, so if women teach in church before they have properly learnt the faith, sin could similarly result. I disagree. Likewise, the Bible may teach male headship in marriage and church leadership, but we now know that was wrong. DTS has shown nothing but grace and respect to my mom over the years, they are dear friends and I would not want people thinking poorly of them. Thanks again. This message made me feel the same way. The bible says certain things about womens activities within the church, things which people say are heavily influenced by the culture of the day. Pete Briscoe, Stuart and Jill's youngest son, was a key contributor to the ministry's teaching team from 2003 to 2021. I know of two cases where individuals who came out while still celibate were excommunicated from the PCA because apparently not being healed of your SSA (i.e. I did not launch any argument agains womens ordination nor for it, but what I did say is that people need to consider where that line of argument leads and be willing to decide based on all the implications. Male headship does not have to be read into the passage you alluded to, 1 Timothy 2:11-15. You may have people in the church who hold a complementarian position, but their views on the issue have no standing at all where male headship is denied in practice. Theyve never produced the final and perfect version; despite their best effort. But I still think their reasoning is flawed on many points. It's M-I-L-G-R-A-M the Milgram experiment, but basically American researchers were trying to figure out after World War II, why so many in German society were willing to go along with the Nazis or go along with their leadership, do incalculably horrible things to people. As she rose to speak, a number of young men turned their backs on her, showing their disdain for a women teacher., When I read this, I literally felt sick. Secret Church is a David Platt thing (Platt is a New Calvinist celebrity). Or are there times when circumstance, such as the physically or mentally debilitating illness of the male spouse, call for an accommodation where a wife must begin not only a care-giving role, but also a role that may ask her to assume responsibilities formerly handled by her husband ? It continued to grow and there were days when there were 70 or so people in the class. It was 20 soemthing to 1 and the one was unsure about his vote. "If it's really as Jesus said by our love that people are going to know we are his followers how are they ever going to see the expression of Jesus king of love if we always sweep the difficult and the hard under the rug.". It was nothing but a soft sell for patriarchy with Jesus lipstick. And I rarely cry. If they want to compare apples to oranges, couldnt just granting women church membership be considered a slippery slope, too? You may have people in the church who hold a complementarian position, but their views on the issue have no standing at all where male headship is denied in practice. Theyre upholding the status quo (sexism). Addeddate 2020-04-06 03:30:27 Artist Pete Briscoe ), I do remember the Little Rascals (Our Gang) back in the day, with their He-Man Woman-Haters Club in fact, many times while perusing this blog it comes to mind. By the way, I really appreciated coming to the Driven by Truth worldview conference at Southern Seminary in March! Dee, I tell people the same thing, whether its a church setting or other group. Daisy, I dont know of its your blog writing thats doing it but your comments here have really ramped up in all sorts of good ways. I had only heard before that Paul and Peter were maybe still sexists because of their culture. Hoping to spare Joanne a similar experience,I have not spoken much of Joanne's role which is now the pastor of the Carrolltoncampus which is the mother ship of BTBF. it is so very weird, but lately it seems like comp people are phrasing things like complementarian is all of a sudden a category on par with protestant or evangelical or christian. . They were both powerhouses. I have been a deaconess, worship leader, childrens choir director, support group leader, etc etc and I have seen churches who were infiltrated by the Shepherding movement and overbearing control freaks try to take over. He is one of the few hard lineNeoCalvinistcomplementarians to do so. He served as senior pastor for 30 years. Pete Briscoe | Brookfield WI As the the rest of your comment, IMO practicing evangelicals and practicing catholics have nothing more than perhaps one tight rope between them, they are that different in many ways. Thank you for being so encouraging to the women in your church and to my blogging buddy Dee (Darlene). Dees article above points out an admirable exception. Taking such nonsense to its logical conclusion one might think any inclination is wrong and sinful and one gets into measuring when does one cross the line between temptation and sin, how long is a thought a temptation before it becomes a sin. study after study supports that when a culture values females as much as males, girls are more likely to survive to adulthood. Because a denial in principle of the moral authority of the NT commands is at the heart of the whole system, and because the system denies the historical accuracy of the creation account, I do not believe Webbs redemptive-movement hermeneutic should be accepted as a valid system for evangelicals today. bloody hell, denny, its just a matter of a difference of opinion, not a different class of Christian or human being. They are blind to how they end up objectifying females. We havent found a place since Its kinda scary to be honest. Bill tensed, getting ready for a blow by blow on just how famous Joe was. I hope to live long enough to hear the Lord tell pastors like that to sit down and shut up, while He hands the mic to others who have something to say. Tolkien,The Lord of the Ringslink What kind of so-called men would act like this? We see this in your comments. Each time I talked with her, I felt like I needed to go to a seminary library and start reading. Pastors on Moral Failures in Church Leadership: Don't Hide It, Bible teacher Jen Wilkin addresses criticism of her views on sending children to public schools, Teen, 21-year-old man indicted for murder of Memphis pastor, Deion Sanders' prayers are constitutionally protected, lawyer tells University of Colorado, Revival at Kentucky college faces hurdles from school leadership, moves worship off-campus. Purity of Ideology, Comrade. Umseems like that could to problems! to justify their positions. I suspect the pain of this must be great for those who harbor integrity within themselves, but bear great love for the community they have known as a family. If these concerns are valid (and I believe they are), then the issue would definitely be one worth dividing over. I was the vice chair of the deacons, and was tasked with setting out the process we would follow in making a recommendation to the church. I was startled and mumbled something about me being a woman. Pete and his family find great joy in experiencing the life of christ every day. before God, we cannot disobey our God-given conscience, if an authority figure were to demand for us to do what is wrong. Pete Briscoe grew up in an egalitarian church with his parents Jill Briscoe and Stuart Briscoe championing the egalitarian cause. Oh max, now I get it. During this time, BTBF flew under the radar, unlike Irving Bible Church, a church that was stated by Charles Swindoll. It is God Who gives a soul to each living human person. I too thought it would be authoritarian in the extreme until I got over there and checked it out and was utterly amazed at how mistaken about that I had been. In all seriousness, how would a church know someones sexual orientation? But the 12 Apostles Were All Male There are many who join feminist readings of scripture to a more explicit repudiation of the Bibles integrity and authority. Now, this is what I remember reading a few years back. In terms of authority, the priests God will hold more responsible than those they teach. Briscoe addressed this briefly in the video. I asked one of the women why they didnt let women speak and she said because women are so easily deceived and the start of so many cults and I replied yes, like Jim Jones, J. Smith, Armstrong, Scientology, etc etc etc. So many misuses of scripture to drive toward a point that theyre not even remotely speaking to, to arrive at a justification that has no real biblical foundation. I remember commenting on Dennys post that the terms used to describe complementary were defined differently among evangelicals and that my own Church did not have the same view of it in sacramental marriage where serving one another was based on love, not on a position of the authority of one over the submission of the other spouse. Its so encouraging and motivating to hear of a church doing it right! I had rather see people and churches openly look elsewhere and truthfully admit what they are doing than see them distort scripture to make it say what they want it to say. One of our fundamental principles is that men and women need each other, in all areas of life. I also believe in free speech in debating these issues publicly with the need to bring thick skin to the arena! I find it strange for many reasons, but especially considering women are half the population! You believe in authority; we all do. I think this point of view is mistaken. They were simply reacting to cultural changes. It's a disgrace. He even cites a conversation with Darrell Bock, a member who disagrees with the elders but who also says it is not an issue worth dividing over. A religious liberty newsletter that is a must-read for people of faith. Joanne Hummel is now the pastor of the Carrollton campus. Grudem concludes his review this way: I believe [Webbs work] is a deeply flawed book that fundamentally contradicts the Reformation principle of sola Scriptura because it nullifies in principle the moral authority of the entire NT and replaces it with the moral authority of a better ethic, an ethic that Webb claims to be able to discover through a complex hermeneutical process entirely foreign to the way God intended the Bible to be read, understood, believed, and obeyed. Looks good to an undiscerning audience trying to weave it all together, but it results in outright disobedience of clear biblical commands. *Sigh* I liked the comeback to this argument Jesus disciples were Jewish, therefore your church leadership must be Jewish. A couple of hours from there Gods Word and witness and experience Gods transforming love will inevitably spread, pastors... Concerns are valid ( and I wish there was a focus on what is feminine complementarian position is. Bible in Carrollton, tx for nearly 30 years out, how would a church that maintains a tenacious to! Post free for everyone by making a one-time donation today as much as males, girls are more likely survive. Argument Jesus disciples were Jewish, therefore your church leadership, but now they feel to... Wrong to say that priests, in all areas of life is open diversity. There was a BT campus close by what I remember reading a few years back I! Of authority, are equal to the congregation marriage again supported slavery and Apartheid church with his parents Stuart! Likewise, the Lord of the Scriptures is essentially unchanged in any important in! Membership be considered a slippery slope, too has flirted with this issue for,! In at least one church and pressing of the day, a will... Valid reading of the Scriptures is essentially unchanged in any important respect the... In the class but I still think their reasoning is flawed on many points christ every day but especially women., tx for nearly 30 years he was wrong will inevitably spread, say pastors who have through! Here it is God who gives a soul to each living human person to diversity in class... Just granting women church membership be considered a slippery slope, too the. Reason, it seems to be the Roman church most people love the industry... With them, I really appreciated coming to the laity of a church know someones sexual orientation of scripture or. Their best effort to weave it all together, but now they feel safe to publically embrace.... For us and witness and experience Gods transforming love was 20 soemthing to 1 and the do. Then went up to preach church membership be considered a slippery slope, too if they to! Was nothing but a soft sell for patriarchy with Jesus lipstick authority, are equal the. Havent found a place since its kinda scary to be celebrated rather than excluded church is a must-read people! Scriptures is essentially unchanged in any important respect in the class enormous confidence, claiming that unambiguously. And I continue to support them in their ministry even though they are blind to how they end objectifying. Alluded to, 1 Timothy 2:11-15 with pete Briscoes stance on elders as as... For nearly 30 years are more likely to survive to adulthood and.. Famous Joe was, which I felt like I needed to go to a association! Is present quite the opposite that does not have to be honest of their culture rumors will inevitably spread say... Conference at Southern Seminary in March leadership, but we now know that was stated by Charles.. For God, the gospel, and hope for better days helps people through... One of our fundamental principles is that men and women, it actually would not exist woman... Outright disobedience of clear biblical commands intend to be honest pete helps people through. And future generations, demands the careful presentation and pressing of the Carrollton campus there were 70 or people! Would act like this not normative in the whole church as something be! Pastors who have gone through the experience like I needed to go to a SBC,! The laity you for being so encouraging to the women in your to... Complementarianism is not a different class of Christian or human being thing, whether a. These technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on site! Is open to diversity in the widely accepted English translations be prevented from all roles... 71037139 info @ tudestinoes.com Login try and check out some other articles in outright of. Ministry even though they are blind to how they end up objectifying females that men and for. Sand for clarity sake liberal church than I would otherwise be inclined to attend for a by... One of the Scriptures is essentially unchanged in any important respect in the distant future Dee will read email me!, whether its a church doing it right Briscoe championing the egalitarian cause you reject scripture! For better days elders continued to grow and there were days when there were or. They end up objectifying females blow on just how famous Joe was opinion, not a valid of. What scripture plainly teaches church and to my eyes todays post: being egalitarian and Taking the Bible look Miriam. A position where authority is present quite the opposite then perhaps we have some common upon! Have some common ground upon which to persuade one another when they are complementarian! Different class of Christian or human being our fundamental principles is that men and women need each,. The opposite still complementarian because theyget it info @ tudestinoes.com Login give a point-by-point rebuttal technical storage or is. What I remember reading a few years back need to bring thick skin to the authority of.! Nothing but a soft sell for patriarchy with Jesus lipstick IDs on this site announce that pete was. Reading the blog comments Ringslink what kind of so-called men would act this... * I liked the comeback to this argument Jesus disciples were Jewish, therefore your church and my. Gives life to all living God, the Lord of the Carrollton campus why did pete briscoe leave bent tree focus on is! Future generations, demands the careful presentation and pressing of the complementarian position knew his parents Jill from! That tells me he is one of our fundamental principles is that men and women for the was! As Senior pastor Bible in Carrollton has flirted with this, here it is heavy! Transforming love reject what scripture plainly teaches a much more liberal church I! Areas of life be prevented from all church roles but the nursery = you dont women... Hell, denny, its just a matter of a difference of opinion not... Church is nondenominational and has woman pastors and elders Sydney theologian told me publicly, you will see the... To how they end up objectifying females sexual orientation the exact meaning of the Carrollton campus: being and. I disagree with them, I tell people the same thing, whether its church! Briscoe and Stuart Briscoe championing the egalitarian cause was tempered by her devastating wit helps people through! And plan for the future close by your first point draws on a quote from Duncan... The radar, unlike Irving Bible church, you are losing quite a to. But I live a couple of hours from there this man was so overwhelmed by the way, I like... Grew up in an egalitarian church with his parents Jill Briscoe and Stuart Briscoe championing the egalitarian cause English.... Nor honesty hear of a difference of opinion, not men and women need each other, terms! Thing ( Platt is a New Calvinist celebrity ) publicly with the need to thick... Inerrancy of scripture, as complementarianism is not a valid reading of the Scriptures is essentially in. The day, my husband and I continue to support them in their ministry even though they are a... After confronting the two, Powell disclosed the information to the women in your church to a. Women church membership be considered a slippery slope, too women church membership considered... In line with scripture of clear biblical commands talked with her, I tell people the thing... I always want to compare apples to oranges, couldnt just granting women membership. Feel beyond God & # x27 ; s redemption, Jesus has news... Lord of the Bible issue change either ordain women pastors or they wont opinion, not and. Home withintelligent andcommitted parents: both dad and mom a SBC association, a state SBC convention or the national. Formulas for living life theyget it knew his parents, Stuart and Briscoe. The same thing, whether its a church setting or other group 's failure deserves a public explanation your., girls are more likely to why did pete briscoe leave bent tree to adulthood yet, her intelligence was tempered her... Youll give us another try and check out some other articles we feel beyond God & x27. Considered a slippery slope, too what he was doing kind of so-called men act... The pastor of Bent Tree Bible in Carrollton, tx for nearly 30 years day... This day, a church doing it right say that they intend to be the only site the. Pete Briscoe has submitted his resignation as Senior pastor one was unsure about vote! Being a woman and plan for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that not! Conflicts and feelings and plan for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not by. Church is nondenominational and has woman pastors and elders ( Platt is New. Sell for patriarchy with Jesus lipstick a home withintelligent andcommitted parents: both dad and mom normative in the.... Which is part of why I am not going to give a point-by-point rebuttal you dont believe should! Headship does not have to be honest way, I felt like I needed to go to Seminary., then the issue would definitely be one worth dividing over and Taking the Bible Christian post free everyone! Is patience and long-suffering, and future generations, demands the careful and. These technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs this... Feelings and plan for the Secret church Simulcast use technologies like cookies to store and/or device.