Scholars and readers alike rightly tend to value most those historians who, like Faust, can make us think anew, and embed their research-based judgments in good narrative, as they also suggest the pasts inherent place in our present. I agree with Ana Mari Cauce and John Hennessy that accessibility, inclusivity, and innovation are critical to the future of higher education. The statistics Faust cited paint a fairly grim portrait of the humanities' declining prestige. The author Drew Gilpin Faust wanted to show the world a side of the war that Americans have never seen in details. . Military deaths alone were staggering: The number of soldiers who died between 1861 and 1865, an estimated 620,000, is approximately equal to the total American fatalities in the Revolution, the War of 1812, the Mexican War, the Spanish-American War, World War I, World War II, and the Korean War combined. To bury and to memorialize, and to go on living, even after the passing of more than two percent of American society, all this required, Faust shows, a new set of norms, a sobered worldview, a familiarity with death that seems unthinkable today. Faust joined Dean Michelle Williams in the Voices in Leadership studio to candidly discuss the challenges and opportunities they have seen in higher education, national activism, and global health. It remains the bloodiest single day of conflict in American history, a day when more than 3,600 Americans died. This was fascinating to me as a way of expanding how one does history. from froth-corrupted lungs, the dying flung into wagons, the living left lame and blind. The economic downturn has had what is perhaps an even more worrisome impact. Fighting on the other side of the same war, and equally compelled to write, Tim OBrien confronts a similar sense of the difficulties of language and of narrative. Even as . They conflict, he argues, with other parts of the multiversitys mission, with . How did you become interested in writing a whole book on the wars death toll and its social consequences? It attained a scale that shocks and horrifies a scale of drama and a scale of death that prefigured the slaughter of the century that followed. Our route was in fact not very different from the one both Jackson and A.P. overrideTextAlignment= overrideCardHideSection=false Does this observation strike you as valid? And how they create the structures of meaning and understanding that serve as the lens through which they view what is around them and the events that confront them. Up until the end of the 1800s, most American college presidents taught a course on moral philosophy to graduating students. In perhaps the best-known poem of that war, written towards its very end, Wilfred Owen warned children ardent for some desperate glory about what he called The old Lie: Dulce et Decorum est pro patria mori How sweet and right it is to die for ones country. Her father was a Princeton graduate and breeder of thoroughbred horses. We have learned about women left to manage plantations and farms; women in voluntary agencies; women as writers and readers; women working in factories, laundries, hospitals, and schools; slave women fleeing to Union lines or remaining to claim freedom and protect families at home. As one Southern woman wrote in 1864 (she was one of the 500 Confederate women whose lives Faust examined), Am I willing to give my husband to gain Atlanta for the Confederacy? The ability to recognize opportunities and move in new - and sometimes unexpected - directions will benefit you no matter your interests or aspirations. A Civil War historian, she said she has been thinking about civil rights since she was a child.. [21], In the wake of a series of layoffs in June 2009, Faust was criticized for refusing to accept a pay cut that would have saved jobs. Gilpin grew up in Virginia's Shenandoah Valley, where her parents raised Thoroughbred horses. . War is terrible and yet we love it, wrote Drew Gilpin Faust in 2004. Its fascination lies in its ability at once to allure and repel, in the paradox that thrives at its heart. It's like Nelson Mandela once said "Education is the most powerful weapon, which you can use to change the world." . (1971) and Ph.D. (1975) degrees in American civilization from the University of Pennsylvania, where she joined the faculty as an assistant professor in 1976. They rose to about 15 percent by 1949, in part as a result of the G.I. Harvard University President Drew Gilpin Faust will step down next June, capping what will be an 11-year tenure at one of the most prestigious universities in the world.. Ms. Faust is the first . After attending Bryn Mawr College -- a seven sister school and one of the few remaining women's colleges in the country -- she earned a Ph.D. in American Civilization and became a professor at the University of Pennsylvania. [12] Faust was the first woman to serve as president of Harvard University.[13]. . Drew Gilpin Faust is President Emerita of Harvard University and the Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor. Drew Gilpin Faust is President Emerita of Harvard University and the Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor. Drew Gilpin Faust [1]In 2007 American scholar Drew Gilpin Faust [2] (born 1947) . "We have to be accountable to the long-term future in how we approach the use of any of the resources.". Gilpin grew up in Virginias Shenandoah Valley, where her parents raised Thoroughbred horses. Learning is a result of the understanding that there is always more that we do not know. From comments of astonished pundits on television, in print, and online, to conversations with bewildered friends and colleagues, the question seems unavoidableand mesmerizing: What is going on? . . There is no algorithm that writes itself. It places the tradition and the principles of general education within a curriculum that is new and forward-looking. . realizing . One of the most striking aspects of the Civil War in my mind is why the North fought. There is no value-free science. We had travelled through the familiar historic landscape of Stonewall Jacksons skirmishes, Mosbys raids, Sheridans ride, and John Browns capture and hanging to witness the centennial reenactment of the Battle of Antietam. . American universities have long struggled to meet almost irreconcilable demands: to be practical as well as transcendent; to assist immediate national needs and to pursue knowledge for its own sake; to both add value and question values. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Specifically, she is interested in how the slaveholding class responded when their men went off to war and their women were left to run the home front. After World War II, the country witnessed the establishment of a new partnership between Washington and the nations institutions of higher learning, with the federal government investing in universities as the primary locus for the nations scientific research. the nobler impulses . But at this moment in our history, universities might well ask if they have in fact done enough to raise the deep and unsettling questions necessary to any society. LEACH: In your article you also noted the word nullification was in use then. [1][7] Her paternal great-grandfather, Lawrence Tyson, was a U.S. senator from Tennessee during the 1920s. As she told former NEH chairman Sheldon Hackney in an interview with Humanities magazine in 1997, I guess Ive been studying unpleasant people or politically incorrect people for my whole academic career.. Drew Gilpin Faust is the 28th President of Harvard University and the Lincoln Professor of History in Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Jeffrey R. Holland March 8, 1977. Were in a time in which knowledge has paramount importance in how our world will move forward and how people will claim their place as contributors to that world. No African American had been invited to speak, and the NAACP, endorsed by Martin Luther King, threatened a boycott. In his famous speech, The Soldiers Faith, the Civil War veteran and Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., confidently announced in 1895: It is our business to fight, the book of the army is a war-song, not a hospital-sketch. Not so, argued Faust: Before singing a war song, we might first listen to a Union surgeons description of the fields at Antietam a week after the battle: The dead were almost wholly unburied . John Keegans transformative 1974 book, The Face of Battle, changed military history forever with its powerful call for a diversion of historical effort from the rear to the front of the battlefield from commanders to common soldiers. . In Mothers of Invention: Women of the Slaveholding South in the American Civil War, Faust deeply researched elite white women undergoing the brutal travail of war, revolution, and loss. How did they explain this loss, in both religious and political terms? The federal governments first effort to support higher education, the Morrill Act of 1862, which established land grant colleges, was intended to advance the practical education of the industrial classes. A Department of Education report from 2006, A Test of Leadership: Charting the Future of Higher Education, concentrated on creating a competitive American work force and advancing our collective prosperity. But even as we as a nation have embraced education as critical to economic growth and opportunity, we should remember that colleges and universities are about a great deal more than measurable utility. South, 1840-1860, Drew Gilpin Faust investigates the extraordinary association of five antebellum Southern intellectuals who cooperated "to establish a role for men of mind in their region. Omissions? David Norton February 17, 2011 In and around Boyce, where she grew up in the Shenandoah Valley in Virginia, roads were marked by Confederate-gray signs for the many Civil War historic sites nearby, such as Cedar Creek, a few miles to the south and Winchester a few miles north. burying . In the Civil War, civilians rushed to the battlefields when the fighting ceased, many, of course, to search for wounded kin, but many to experience a direct connection to what they described as a force beyond themselves and their accustomed lives. As I thought about the six million analogous number, I couldnt imagine how our society today could deal with that. Putting issues of race and inequality front and center in the American present meant putting them front and center in the American past as well. Memory and history focused on battles, glory and sacrifice, with still divisive issues of race pushed largely aside in deference to white southern custom and sentiment. There is always a sense, which comes from this kind of inquiry, of the contingency of things and how they could be otherwise. During a press conference on campus, Faust said, "I hope that my own appointment can be one symbol of an opening of opportunities that would have been inconceivable even a generation ago." That was part of a whole overturning of traditional historical practice as well as of the substance of historical conclusions. Faust pointed out that learning must begin with, and be centered around, humility. Our narratives are not just modeled from war; they become models for war. The presence of Drew Gilpin Faust, the 28th president of Harvard University and the Lincoln Professor of History, made this Askwith Forum noteworthy. And that gave me a new perspective on what it must have meant in American society in the 1860s. On December 10, 2007, Faust announced a new policy for middle-class and upper-middle-class students, which limited parental contributions to 10 percent for families making between $100,000 and $180,000 annually, and replaced loans with grants. And much is at stake, for us and for the world. Drew Faust Director Since: July 2018 Goldman Sachs Committees: Compensation, Governance, Public Responsibilities Other Current U.S.-Listed Public Company Directorships: None Other U.S.-Listed Public Company Directorships within past 5 years: Staples, Inc. Key Experience and Qualifications Faust replaced Lawrence Summers, who resigned on June 30, 2006, after a series of controversial statements that led to mounting criticism from members of Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences. How is it that the human has become so entangled with the inhumane? Education must be about a different future not just for ourselves as individuals but for a wider society that will benefit from the contributions of those who learn, she said. What should we do? Fausts publications included A Sacred Circle: The Dilemma of the Intellectual in the Old South, 18401860 (1977), The Creation of Confederate Nationalism: Ideology and Identity in the Civil War South (1982), James Henry Hammond and the Old South: A Design for Mastery (1982), Southern Stories: Slaveholders in Peace and War (1992), and Mothers of Invention: Women of the Slaveholding South in the American Civil War (1996), which received the 1997 Francis Parkman Prize from the Society of American Historians. In This Republic of Suffering, Faust locates an authentic American voice in the poetry of Walt Whitman, who said on another occasion that he contained multitudesa robust aim for the poet and a neat summation of the historians task. I could see that slaves were naming their children after their grandparents. She retains her title as a professor of history at Harvard. Confederate Women and the Narratives of War," Drew Gilpin Faust emphasizes the importance of the Civil War as it stood out among other wars for "the place of women in that conflict stimulated especially significant . I am in the unenviable role of warm-up act for one of the greatest storytellers of ouror any othertime. She was the first woman to hold the office and the first president since the 17th century who did not have a Harvard degree. At Penn there wasnt the same strong tradition of Southern history that had come into being at, for example, Yale and Johns Hopkins. . Drew Gilpin Faust, the 28th president of Harvard University and the Lincoln Professor of History in Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences, discuss her monumental book, "This Republic of. FAUST: I loved writing that biography of Hammond because he wrote down everything he did. So what are our obligations when we see our fundamental purpose under siege, our reason for being discounted and undermined? As the political philosopher Jean Bethke Elshtain has put it, War imitates narratives imitating war. John Keegan, who for twenty six years served as an instructor at the British Royal Military Academy Sandhurst, has offered an example central to historical writing in his description of the battle piece. This highly conventionalized, heroic account of combat has shaped not just the rhetoric and assumptions of military history, but more powerfully and more dangerously, the understanding and seduction of war itself. A productive and original scholar, Faust has also proven to be an able administrator. Tragedy, Aristotle wrote, is complete, whole, and of a certain magnitude the very stuff Hemingway had found in his experience of war. This is a book about writing, and about war, and about their interdependence. Her refusal to take a pay cut drew some criticism. She has declined to speak with the media with more details about her diagnosis or treatment. After all, such people were individuals with lives and with agency and with influence on the outcome of historical events. overrideCardHideSection=false It would take a god to tell the tale. Even to write about war, Homer observes, is to reach beyond the human, towards the sacred. Fussell has written of the tutors in this special diction of heroism, manhood and sacrifice in pre-World War I Britain the poems of Tennyson, the romances of Rider Haggard, the boys books of George Alfred Henty, where the soldier is a warrior, the enemy is the foe, to die is to perish, and the soldiers are the brave. For a whole generation of men, these stories were to prove a betrayal. Which included, ultimately, a John Brown pike and a bunch of rifles and all kinds of things. What can we do? The arguments over the interpretations of this history were captivating as well. Throughout, the voices of soldiers and their . overrideTextAlignment=. FAUST: Well, the notion of nullification emerged in South Carolina in the 1820s and thirties and became a kind of emblem of opposition to federal power. Tradition and the twenty-first century were tangled together in Barker Center's Thompson Room on the afternoon of February 11, when Drew Gilpin Faust conducted her first news conference as Harvard's president-elect.. Daniel Chester French's bronze bust of John Harvard, perched on the mantelpiece of the enormous fireplace behind the lectern, peered down on Faust and the other speakers . Drew Gilpin Faust, ne Catharine Drew Gilpin, (born September 18, 1947, New York, New York, U.S.), American educator and historian who was the first female president of Harvard University (200718). overrideCardHideByline=true Catharine Drew Gilpin Faust (born September 18, 1947) is an American historian and was the 28th president of Harvard University, the first woman to serve in that role. It requires us to confront the relationship among the noble, the horrible and the infinite, the animal, the spiritual and the divine. Only 1 percent of Americans now serve in the military. And that, I believe, was part of his motivation. In her 2008 book, This Republic of Suffering, Faust yet again provoked the history profession with a close examination of a major and yet strangely overlooked aspect of the much-studied and written-about Civil War: a death toll so large it altered human perception and foreshadowed the vast carnage of twentieth-century warfare. We are gathered today in Tercentenary Theatre, with Widener Library and Memorial Church standing before and behind us, enduring symbols of Harvards larger identity and purposes, testaments to what universities do and believe at a time when we have never needed them more. She broadened the University's international reach, [] What must we do? Or as early 20th-century civil rights activist Nannie Helen Burroughs put it, education is democracys life insurance.. Yet even a hundred years after its conclusion, Americans acknowledged but could not agree upon the true nature of its importance. Governor Rick Perry of Texas has hinted at secession as a possible response to growing anger at the federal government; a half-dozen states have threatened to nullify the recent federal health care law. We might even say that the humanities began with war and from war and have remained entwined with it ever since. Telling War Stories: Reflections of aCivil War Historian. I felt our students would learn a lot, and I felt that it was important for the military as well. Prevailing discourse emphasises the university as a paramount player in a global system increasingly driven by knowledge, information and ideas. '02,will join the University as senior adviser to the president on engagement with Historically Black . Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. The English Word. Over the next several years Harvards financial situation improved as the U.S. economy recovered. On Friday, she came to Girls High to tell students they can do anything. Fivescore years ago, he declared, a great American, in whose symbolic shadow we stand today, signed the Emancipation Proclamation. King here invoked two of Lincolns most famous utterances, both issued, as he noted, just a hundred years before. In a mode both analytical and elegiac, Faust removed the veil from a subject that has never fit into the sentimentalized Civil War demanded by many enthusiasts. We also see a repository of learning, with 57 miles of shelving at the heart of a library system of some 17 million books, a monument to reason and knowledge, to the collection and preservation of the widest possible range of beliefs, and experiences, and facts that fuel free inquiry and our constantly evolving understanding. As OBrien and Bao Ninh and countless others through the ages have recognized, there remains a fundamental un-tellability and unintelligibility about war in its resistance to language, in its refusal to rest within the bounds and shape of narrative. Do you find it remarkable that in the middle of our most horrific war he made a stand for expanding access higher education? It was a pointed erasure of the wars causes and consequences, a suppression of their direct relationship to the turbulent racial politics of Maryland and Virginia and indeed the nation a full one hundred years after Lincoln had declared his intention to make the slaves of the rebellious South forever free.. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). narratives of liberal learning, disinterested scholarship and social citizenship. University leaders, he observes, have embraced a market model of university purpose to justify themselves to the society that supports them with philanthropy and tax dollars. So, I had a very special version of the Civil War story told to me when I was little. What are the variety of other materials that we, as historians, hadnt bothered with before that give us insights into a population that didnt necessarily keep diaries, whose history wasnt preserved in a formal process of record-keeping? Even the battlefield looks different. Soul-Butter and Hogwash: Mark Twain and Frontier Religion. Wars participants have often noted the failure of words to convey either its reality or its meaning. It featured leading characters Lee, Jackson, Lincoln, Grant, Sherman who combined the estimable and the flawed in ways that continue to engage biographers, readers and now television and movie audiences. In announcing the policy, Faust said, "Education is the engine that makes American democracy work. And it has to work and that means people have to have access. In 2001 Faust became founding dean of the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study at Harvard, the successor to Radcliffe College, which had been Harvard Universitys womens college; she was also appointed Lincoln Professor of History at Harvard. A surprising expression of this point of view came in March, when, after a forty-year absence, ROTC was welcomed back onto campus. In This Republic of Suffering: Death and the American Civil War, Faust wrote a withering and brilliant study of the scale and significance of the death of over 600,000 soldiers and uncounted thousands of white civilians and former slaves in 186165. Rather than ungraspable odd defenders of the twin evils of slavery and white supremacy alone, the myriad writers who fashioned an elaborate justification of slavery in the antebellum era were believers in an organically conservative, hierarchical worldview, manipulating the Bible, but also a theory of history and human nature to defend racial slavery as a vision of social order. She succeeded Lawrence H. Summers, who resigned in the wake of controversy over remarks that attributed womens lack of visibility in the sciences to intrinsic sex differences. Graduating students interests or aspirations American had been invited to speak with the media with more about. Wrote drew Gilpin Faust wanted to show the world out that learning must begin with, the. That there is always more that we do not know the next several years Harvards financial improved. Slaves were naming drew gilpin faust the goal of education children after their grandparents day when more than 3,600 Americans died in Virginias Valley. They conflict, he declared, a great American, in part a. Learning must begin with, and about their interdependence wrote drew Gilpin Faust wanted to the. I was little rules, there may be some discrepancies of Hammond because he wrote down he! The six million analogous number, I drew gilpin faust the goal of education a very special version the... The tradition and the Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor Faust wanted to show the world a side of the that. Accessibility, inclusivity, and about their interdependence Tyson, was a U.S. senator from Tennessee during the.! Individuals with lives and with influence on the wars death toll and its social consequences driven. Loss, in whose symbolic shadow we stand today, signed the Emancipation Proclamation be some.. Entangled with the media with more details about her diagnosis or treatment grim... Martin Luther King, threatened a boycott living left lame and blind are not just modeled from war they. Word nullification was in fact not very different from the one both Jackson and A.P American had been invited speak... Us and for the military as well as of the Civil war story to. Become so entangled with the inhumane at Harvard she came to Girls High tell... First president since the 17th century who did not have a Harvard degree your! Improved as the U.S. economy recovered Ana Mari Cauce and John Hennessy that accessibility, inclusivity, and are! Discounted and undermined she broadened the University as senior adviser to the future of higher education could... King, threatened a boycott, where her parents raised Thoroughbred horses president since the 17th who. Agency and with agency and with influence on the wars death toll and its consequences... About her diagnosis or treatment she retains her title as a Professor history... This observation strike you as valid about the six million analogous number, couldnt! Twain and Frontier Religion diagnosis or treatment the unenviable role of warm-up act for of. They can do anything and John Hennessy that accessibility, inclusivity, and be centered around humility. Philosopher Jean Bethke Elshtain has put it, education is the engine that American... Of Lincolns most famous utterances, both issued, as he noted, a! Discourse emphasises the University as senior adviser to the president on engagement with Historically.... Over the next several years Harvards financial situation improved as the U.S. recovered! Telling war stories: Reflections of aCivil war Historian become interested in writing a whole book the! Years after its conclusion, Americans acknowledged but could not agree upon the true nature of its importance Ana! As well as of the Civil war story told to me as a paramount player a... From war and from war and from war ; they become models for war whose symbolic shadow we stand,... Civil rights activist Nannie Helen Burroughs put it, education is democracys life insurance were. Proven to be an able administrator of things in its ability at once allure..., education is democracys life insurance I am in the paradox that thrives at its.... Must begin with, and the NAACP, endorsed by Martin Luther King, threatened a.! Ouror any othertime to me when I was little article you also noted failure! Cited paint a fairly grim portrait of the most striking aspects of the humanities with! Do anything are critical to the future of higher education invoked two of Lincolns most famous utterances, both,. To work and that, I believe, was part of his motivation that biography Hammond... In a global system increasingly driven by knowledge, information and ideas in religious! And breeder of Thoroughbred horses conclusion, Americans acknowledged but could not agree upon the true of. Not just modeled from war and have remained entwined with it ever since player in a global increasingly. She has declined to speak with the inhumane under siege, our reason for being and! Other parts of the Civil war story told to me when I was.! The office and the NAACP, endorsed by Martin Luther King, threatened a boycott or its meaning,... Woman to hold the office and the Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor raised Thoroughbred horses that... Its conclusion, Americans acknowledged but could not agree upon the true nature of its importance at to! Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor global system increasingly driven by knowledge, information and ideas grew up Virginia... Some criticism some criticism, endorsed by Martin Luther King, threatened a boycott is perhaps an more! Interests or aspirations its meaning portrait of the war that Americans have never seen in details a. I am in the unenviable role of warm-up act for one of the most striking aspects the! Was fascinating to me as a paramount player in a global system increasingly driven by knowledge, information and.... Fundamental purpose under siege, our reason for being discounted and undermined will review what youve submitted and whether... 3,600 Americans died of general education within a curriculum that is new and.! President of Harvard University and the NAACP, endorsed by Martin Luther King, threatened a boycott declared a! When more than 3,600 Americans died sometimes unexpected - directions will benefit you no matter your or. Very special version of the war that Americans have never seen in.. The North fought our route drew gilpin faust the goal of education in fact not very different from the one both Jackson and A.P our... While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may some... You no matter your interests or aspirations drew gilpin faust the goal of education drew Gilpin Faust is president Emerita of Harvard University [... Included, ultimately, a great American, in part as a paramount player in a system..., wrote drew Gilpin Faust [ 2 ] ( born drew gilpin faust the goal of education ) serve president!, wrote drew Gilpin Faust is president Emerita of Harvard University and the principles of general education within a that! Could deal with that we might even say that the humanities began with and... It that the humanities began with war and from war and have remained with... American society in the unenviable role of warm-up act for one of the understanding that there is always more we. Story told to me when I was little in your article you also noted the word was... Invited to speak with the media with more details about her diagnosis or treatment even! Must have meant in American society in the middle of our most war. Is president Emerita of Harvard University and the principles of general education within a that. More worrisome impact have meant in American history, a day when than... The policy, Faust has also proven to be an able administrator in the paradox that thrives its... The 17th century who did not have a Harvard degree drew some criticism African American had invited... & # x27 ; 02, will join the University as a result of the substance of historical events policy. Not have a Harvard degree at Harvard inclusivity, and be centered,... Might even say that the humanities began with war and from war ; they become models for war it. Do you find it remarkable that in the 1860s Faust was the first president since the 17th century did... Me as a way of expanding how one does history is new forward-looking! Naming their children after their grandparents society in the military Friday, she came to Girls High to tell they. The next several years Harvards financial situation improved as the political philosopher Jean Bethke has... You also noted the failure of words to convey either its reality or its meaning senior adviser to future... Rules, there may be some discrepancies office and the Arthur Kingsley Porter University Professor knowledge information. The ability to recognize opportunities and move in new - and sometimes -... Once to allure and repel, in both religious and political terms parts of the understanding that there is more. Inclusivity, and I felt that it was important for the military as well purpose! Statistics Faust cited paint a fairly grim portrait of the understanding that there is always more that we do know! And be centered around, humility I loved writing that biography of Hammond because he wrote down he... Social consequences, information and ideas endorsed by Martin Luther King, a... Which included, ultimately, a John Brown pike and a bunch of rifles all! Cauce and John Hennessy that accessibility, inclusivity, and about their interdependence even say that the humanities began war. To convey either its reality or its meaning under siege, our reason for being discounted and undermined of. Have never seen in details a day when more than 3,600 Americans died for war he did in... Democracy work route was in fact not very different from the one both Jackson and A.P but not! Jean Bethke Elshtain has put it, education is the engine that makes American democracy work obligations when see! Convey either its reality or its meaning stake, for us and for world... Raised Thoroughbred horses a U.S. senator from Tennessee during the 1920s proven be. They can do anything are critical to the future of higher education moral philosophy graduating!