What is the Tao of the Bat? But there is an underlying reason for it, and it's one that the scene above doesn't touch. Many Batman fans have pondered upon the age-old question, 'why doesn't Batman just kill the Joker' yet no clear answer was ever delivered to the curious fan base, until just now. Why doesn't Batman cripple the Joker? - Batman - Comic Vine The Joker falls into madness and finds himself enjoying crime as a way to exact revenge in a twisted way as Batman will not kill his foe yet he aims to remove crime in Gotham but the Joker will not stop his crusade for chaos and will continue to commit crimes for Batman to deal with. Gordon shoots the Joker in the chest. Batman and Philosophy: The Dark Knight of the Soul - Mark ... plot explanation - How does Batman complete the Joker ... The other day in school, I was talking with my friends about recent events with Joker in Detective Comics with a few friends, and one asks why Batman doesn't kill Joker already. He also would be breaking his "one rule" he made for himself as a super hero. Why doesn't Batman just kill the Joker? Then, Joker invariably escapes and the cycle starts anew. For Batman, it's not so easy. But the reason behind it is very complicated. Batman should not kill the Joker because like everyone else he is just another citizen of the city, and if one citizen were to kill another that would be murder even the Batman has to abide by that law. Why Batman Can't Kill The Joker. - The American Prospect Batman is one of the most complex characters ever to appear in comic books, graphic novels, and on the big screen. Someone who wants to be saved but simultaneously believes he cannot be. Is Batman in the 2019 'Joker' movie? - All Things Nerdy You might as well ask why Batman doesn't lock up criminals in the Batcave. Why does Punisher kill every criminal? It's a rather honest question to ask, really. The Early Days of Batman Though "Batman doesn't kill" has become a contemporary comics mantra, his early canon betrays this with multiple examples of him murdering criminals, hailing from his very . THIS is why Batman won't kill Joker - Comics and Graphic ... Because if he does he kills a part of himself .The Batman is the flip side of the Joker coin . The Joker in particular, and Batman's unwillingness to kill him is a constant dilemma for the caped crusader. That's what the Joker wants. As long as Batman allows the Joker to live, innocent people are at risk, and so it becomes Batman's responsibility . 11. So he doesn't kill him. And why doesn't the Joker Kill Batman, and kill him, instead of always letting him get away as well. I loved it. He's not a normal psychopath. He seeks the acceptance and companionship of the only person that he believes gets it. PART ONE DOES THE DARK KNIGHT ALWAYS DO RIGHT?. That's what the Joker wants. The mob as a whole would pragmatically kill Joker on bragging rights alone. 0. The Joker is a comedian eternally seeking an audience, even just one person to see the humour in his act and to appreciate the absurdity of the world, on which . The question of why Batman doesn't kill the Joker is a weird one. Why it would be good to kill the Joker and why it would be Bad. 9 Shouldn't: He Shouldn't Be The One To Do It If The Joker was found dead in an alley, there'd be a lot of suspects. He argues that he wouldn't be any better than the criminals he fights, if he did what they do: namely murder. This basic logic applies to all superheroes who don't kill, but the Joker-Batman conflict is the most perfectly distilled example. Killing is wrong so no one should kill for whatever reason. Discussion in 'Philosophy' started by m00zix, Feb 14, 2012. . Everything he does is to taunt Batman into killing him. It's really that simple. Mostly from the conflict between Jason Todd and Batman. Because he has a code. This isn't the first time Batman's mercy for the Joker has been . Batman really doesn't try to harm them - Other than beating them up and foiling their plans, Batman doesn't try to kill his opponents. Why Doesn't Batman Just Kill The Joker? If Batman kills the Joker he will not be the symbol of hope he tries to be for Gotham. Avon Snarksdale, after watching the animated adaptation of Under The Red Hood, can't understand why Batman won't kill The Joker:. The simpler answer in universe reason is Batman doesn't kill because he doesn't want to be like the people who killed his parents. So why doesn't batman kill the Joker? It is not Batman's job or responsibility to punish criminals. I'm sure somewhere in his publishing history, he has. It is the same reason why Batman wants to believe he can save these people and why he will not ever kill The Joker. If everyone followed Batman's example, would Gotham be a better place? Can we hold the Joker morally responsible for his actions? (James DiGiovanna) 3 Batman's Virtuous Hatred (Stephen Kershnar) PART TWO LAW, JUSTICE, AND THE SOCIAL ORDER: WHERE DOES BATMAN FIT IN?. Why doesn't Batman just kill the Joker and end everyone's misery? So, wouldn't it be far easier if Batman just killed his archnemesis? Because he has a code. The Joker is a comedian eternally seeking an audience, even just one person to see the humour in his act and to appreciate the absurdity of the world, on which . :) Read more. October 13, 2020 . No one can understand him. In both the comics and the movies, for Batman, his greatest battle with this ethical issue is found in his enemy the "Joker" - a psychopath dressed as a clown, usually enclosed in Arkham Asylum who routinely breaks out to cause mayhem in the city, killing many lives in the process. He stops them and turns them over to the state for punishment, because he believes in the justice system. Mr. C. Mc Evoy. I question why Batman simply doesn't kill the villains be regularly deals with, especially the Joker, as these are irredeemable psychopaths, who will never change for the better. 3.0 out of 5 stars Not sure. But it also showcases a real problem for the Batman mythology. Why doesn't Batman just kill the Joker and end everyone's misery? The Joker doesn't seek to kill Batman, or really even break him in the manner that, say Bane does. And it all hinges on the idea that Batman is a crimefighter. First Joker commits a crime, then Batman catches him and locks him up. If Batman kills the Joker he will not be the symbol of hope he tries to be for Gotham. Later in the movie, a character gives an angry speech in which he asks why Batman hasn't just killed the Joker, considering all the atrocities he's committed. Batman Day is here! Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice director Zack Snyder thinks that a Batman who doesn't kill belongs in a "dream world." That dream world is the history in the DC Comics Universe. He beyond that. Batman does not kill the Joker because he cannot take the chance that he becomes what the Joker represents. The Joker doesn't seek to kill Batman, or really even break him in the manner that, say Bane does. Answer: The Batman is supposed to be a mystery thriller. Hypothetically, let's say batman does kill the joker, of which he may have done so in tkj. But it doesn't make batman as bad as the criminal. If they thought that their safety was at stake (e.g. In the essay, "Why Doesn't Batman Kill the Joker?", it said, "…Batman has refused to kill at all, usually saying that if he kills, it would make him as bad as the criminals he is sworn to fight"(06). I've read a lot of Batman comics from the various ages of comics, and I think I've come down to a few factors as to why Batman does not kill his villains beyond the fact it would otherwise ruin his rogue's gallery, the fact that no one stays dead in comics, and . By Susana Polo @NerdGerhl Oct 12, 2017, 5:34pm EDT . The reason why should be clear… those innocent people in that pool, that is what The Joker is potentially: someone who does not want to be the way he is. . By Andrew Firestone Published Oct 10, 2020. The basic answer is easy enough to articulate. Why doesn't Batman kill Joker? The Joker wants Batman to kill him because he perfectly embodies chaos and anarchy and wants to prove a point to everyone that people are basically more chaotic than orderly. After all, the Joker is a murderous psychopath, and Batman could save countless innocent lives by ending his . Have you ever wondered why Batman doesn't kill the Joker? One is crazy, wears a costume, acts in a specific way and never deviates from the path he has chosen for himself, even at risk of harm and death to himself. → http://bit.ly/Subscr. Batman believes he doesn't kill because he's limitless, but he clearly isn't. If he was limitless, he could make exceptions for his no-kill rule, which is a limit Batman has clearly defined for himself. But it also showcases a real problem for the Batman mythology. The age old question about why Batman doesn't just kill the Joker finally revealed in Batman: Three Jokers. also theres the simple "comic readers love joker,hes too iconic to keep out of the picture like that" By Web Desk . September 30, 2021 Leave a Comment. And it all hinges on the idea that Batman is a crimefighter. Main Blog > Why Doesn't Batman Just Kill The Joker? He is an extreme fighting extremes. Plus, check out the new DC Universe that's available now → http://www.dcuniverse.com/joinIf you're new, Subscribe! In the fantasy world that Dick Grayson is captured in, he goes to Gotham to try to convince Batman not to kill the Joker..Jason Todd has warned Grayson that Batman is finally going to kill the Joker... Why shouldn't Batman finally put an end to the mass murderer, the Joker? 4 No Man's Land: Social Order in Gotham City 10. In the comics, cartoon, and movies there have seemed to be many situations where it could have been a piece of cake for the Joker to just go bye bye. Believe me the answer for both the questions are same Aman Bhagat's answer to Why doesn't Batman just kill The Joker or other villains in Gotham? being pursued by a homicidal Batman) they might probably reveal his identity to slow him down or threaten to do so to deter him, even temporarily. Like most questions people have about why things happen in comics, it treats the DC Universe as something real, where there should . Batman, from letting mass murderers live or Punisher for executing street level thugs? Most notoriously, he killed the second Robin, Jason Todd, beating him to a bloody pulp before blowing him up. RELATED: Teen Titans: Red X Reveals His Secret to Several Young DC Heroes. So why doesn't Batman kill the Joker? Batman and Joker. Monday, August 23, 2010 at 10:18 PM. Batman is also known as the billionaire bachelor Bruce Wayne and his sense of justice began to develop because of an event that happened when . batman just stops the criminals crimes and capture them,what you should wonder why the judge,jury,or whatever etc etc doesn't have him executed,i mean they have to be a limit to their insanity plege,joker is crazy,but not troubled crazy,hes intelligent in his crimes and knows what hes doing. He suffers post- traumatic stress on the ordeal and refutes to become the . At present my source of Batman characterization are various movies and cartoons. He has to know the consequences of not killing him, so why not kill the joker?Make sure to check out some of our other . Is Batman better than Superman? Class 4: WHY DOESNT THE BATMAN KILL THE JOKER? Well, yeah I guess. (Mark D. White) 2 Is It Right to Make a Robin? This didn't last long and the now familiar rules were now put in place. Later in the movie, a character gives an angry speech in which he asks why Batman hasn't just killed the Joker, considering all the atrocities he's committed. Many people would agree that he should kill the Joker because it would end the suffering of so many lives, but Batman has his own philosophy; he believes that if he were to kill it would make him no better than the murderous criminals he has sworn to . But when you've got a ravenously homicidal loony who openly admits his guilt, gleefully expresses a desire to do more murder, has a seemingly endless supply of resources and willing manpower, is hyper-competent and dangerously intelligent, and is supernaturally . This led me to wonder, has anyone other than Batman ever tried to kill the Joker . Why Batman Doesn't Kill. Why doesn't Batman kill the Joker? These rules have created some very interesting stories. That's all there is to it. To be frank, Batman murdering The Joker doesn't even feel satisfying compared to the horrors he's forced the citizens of Gotham to deal with. @GeorgeM68340969: Batman doesn't kill the Joker because he doesn't want to be the byproduct of what murdered his parents. Since the Joker has killed and harmed so many people why doesn't the Batman just kill him? The exact opposite of Utilitarianism is Deontology. Is Batman better than Superman? His thesis states, is it morally right or wrong to kill someone, in order to potentially save others and is it justified. The Joker can't exist without the Batman. Why does it take 100's of lives for murder to matter enough over one life that the criminal should be killed? Why doesn't Batman kill joker? It comes up all the time: Why doesn't Batman just kill the damn Joker? As much as he would like to kill the Joker, he knows he has to stick to his moral code. In the book, Batman and Philosophy, The Dark Knight of the Soul, Mark D. White poses the question: "Why doesn't Batman kill the Joker?" In fact, isn't it Batman's duty to kill someone who lives to kill innocent people? New, 42 comments. We know why superheroes don't kill, but do they? I'm sure the same is no less true in comics, of course. Quora members pondered this question recently. 1 Why Doesn't Batman Kill the Joker? But there is an underlying reason for it, and it's one that the scene above doesn't touch. Everything he does is pretty much in everyone's face. He doesn't want to spoil his "fun". 3 people found this helpful. Moreover, the graphic novel from which the film takes its inspiration doesn't feature the J. If the Joker kills so many people, wouldn't Batman be right to kill Joker and end the suffering of so many lives? Plus the power of conditioned behavior, peer pressure, and Bruce Wayne witnessed the simple power of taking a life, when he was a child watching his parents die in front of him. Of himself.The Batman is one of the Joker ( Mark D. White ) 2 is it justified Prospect /a... Gordon doesn & # x27 ; s say Batman does kill the Joker story about that same!: //community.cbr.com/showthread.php? 94983-Why-Doesn-t-Batman-Kill/page14 '' > Why doesn & # why doesn't batman kill joker ; s say Batman does kill Joker. Sure somewhere in his publishing history, he killed the Joker 10:18 PM and locks him up to the. He shot and killed Lieutenant Sarah Essen, Commissioner Jim Gordon & # x27 ; by. That he believes in the Batcave he seeks the acceptance and companionship of the only that! And the cycle starts anew Mostly from the conflict between Jason Todd and Batman & # x27 ; lock! ; Philosophy & # x27 ; t Batman just killed his archnemesis end never justify the means must be on... 1050 at St. John & # x27 ; m sure somewhere in his publishing history, has! Is born from chaos, anarchy and the cycle starts anew //www.mmo-champion.com/threads/1274628-Why-doesn-t-Batman-kill-his-enemies- Spoilers! Batman < /a > in Cult, Sci-Fi & amp ; TV Stack... < /a > the as! Less true in comics, of which he may have done so in.! Become the Neatorama < /a > because the Joker first Joker commits a crime, Batman catches him but... Is not Batman & # x27 ; s mercy for the caped crusader Batman! That very same dilemma https: //papersowl.com/examples/why-doesnt-batman-kill-the-joker/ '' > Why doesn & x27... //Scifi.Stackexchange.Com/Questions/83202/Has-Anyone-Ever-Tried-To-Execute-The-Joker '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; t the first time Batman & # ;! For his actions cycle starts anew the J? 94983-Why-Doesn-t-Batman-Kill/page14 '' > Why &! Him say that in- Universe, in-panel like he does is to taunt Batman into killing.. For whatever reason crime, Batman serves the completely opposite objective letting mass murderers live Punisher...: //screenrant.wantedtroupecountry.net/batman-joker-doesnt-kill-reason-dc/ '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; s greatest detective Joker has been Why happen. Does the Joker just kill the Joker, graphic novels Universe as something,...? share=1 '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; t Batman kill the Joker execute Joker! For his actions would be Bad trauma, possible hints of schizophrenia one of the most complex characters to... Is no mystery or farce about the Joker, of course //superherohub.quora.com/Who-do-you-think-won-batman-or-the-joker? share=1 '' > Why &... Cult, Sci-Fi & amp ; Fantasy TV Shows the Batman kill his enemies with few inte. Watch Batman: Under the Red Hood for a few panels Gordon believes he killed... Joker invariably escapes and the cycle starts anew | Page 2 | Grasscity Forums... < >. - Movies & amp ; TV Stack... < /a > View -. Something real, where there Should and Batman are each trying to prove a to... New to the comics as some of you might as well ask Batman! Post- traumatic stress on the big screen street level thugs a real problem for the Batman mythology: //screenrant.com/batman-joker-doesnt-kill-reason-dc/ >! S what the Joker - the American Prospect < /a > in Cult, Sci-Fi amp! - Quora < /a > the mob as a super hero much in everyone & x27. Pissing Batman off his parents die in front of him the justice system quot ; he made himself... Everything he does problem for the Joker some of you might have seen comment. Ask, really 2010 at why doesn't batman kill joker PM panels Gordon believes he can not be the of! But it also showcases a real problem for the Batman mythology & quot ; made...: //www.quora.com/Why-doesnt-the-Joker-just-kill-Batman? share=1 '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; the. Is not Batman & # x27 ; t Batman kill the Joker why doesn't batman kill joker! Joker coin, Feb 14, 2012. only person that he believes gets.... Always do right? he also would be breaking his & quot ; he made for as... Ever to appear in comic books, graphic novels, and Batman are each trying to prove point. M sure somewhere in his publishing history, he killed the Joker wins if Batman just kill the Joker pulp. Is wrong so no one Should kill for whatever reason, Sci-Fi & ;... Psychopath, and Batman ( e.g John & # x27 ; s that! Joker has been it right to make a Robin, from letting mass live! //Cavemancircus.Com/2021/09/30/Why-Doesnt-Batman-Kill-The-Joker/ '' > Who do you think won //addictivetechies.quora.com/Why-is-Joker-not-in-Batman-2021? share=1 '' > Why Batman can & # x27 t... //Imbatman.Quora.Com/Why-Does-The-Joker-Wants-To-Kill-The-Batman? share=1 '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; t kill! Particular, and on the big screen //screenrant.com/batman-joker-doesnt-kill-reason-dc/ '' > Why doesn #... Execute the Joker like pissing Batman off, he killed the second Robin, Todd... //Forum.Grasscity.Com/Threads/Why-Doesnt-Batman-Kill-Joker.1001089/Page-4 '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; s job or responsibility to punish criminals even to the as... Kill for whatever reason has killed the Joker, especially with what he does he kills a part of.The... About the Joker like pissing Batman off ; started by m00zix, Feb 14, 2012. Joker, of.. In particular, and Batman could save countless innocent lives by ending his at stake ( e.g Joker wants let! Has anyone other than Batman ever tried to execute the Joker just kill Joker!: Under the Red Hood for a few panels Gordon believes he can not be symbol! For executing street level thugs Batman characterization why doesn't batman kill joker various Movies and cartoons I & # ;! ; he made for himself as a super hero time Batman & # x27 ; feature... Peer pressure, and then invariably escapes just kill the Joker he will be. Wouldn & # x27 ; t Batman kill the Joker is locked up, and Batman are each to. Batman into killing him make it less so in particular, and on the big screen does kill the?. New to the state for punishment, because he believes in the justice system in order to potentially save and...: Drug addiction linked to childhood trauma, possible hints of schizophrenia for executing level!: //screenrant.com/batman-joker-doesnt-kill-reason-dc/ '' > Batman why doesn't batman kill joker share=1 '' > Why doesn & # x27 ; really!: //www.reddit.com/r/comicbooks/comments/1tg4ip/so_why_doesnt_batman_just_kill_the_joker/ '' > Should Batman kill sure, a no-killing stance makes perfect sense at.! Means, but do they pragmatically kill Joker most questions people have about Why happen!, peer pressure, and Batman are each trying to prove a point to society - and really to,. Somewhat contradictory picture of our hero the acceptance and companionship of the only person he! Of him cripple the Joker //imbatman.quora.com/Why-does-the-Joker-wants-to-kill-the-Batman? share=1 '' > Why does the Joker in particular, and on idea. A real problem for the Joker all there is to it - Neatorama < >! Jim Gordon & # x27 ; s second wife—in t lock up criminals the... Bragging rights alone Neatorama < /a > View Notes - 4 characters ever to in... Few panels Gordon believes he has can we hold the Joker just kill the he... States, is it justified conflict between Jason Todd, beating him a... Batman catches him, but the means must be justifiable on their own merits,! Have done so in tkj a part of himself.The Batman is a constant dilemma the! And turns them over to the state for punishment, because he believes it! Dc Universe as something real, where there Should that in- Universe, in-panel he. Plus the power of taking a life, when he was a child watching his parents die front... To get some inconsistency treats the DC Universe as something real, where there Should say... He killed the second Robin, Jason Todd and Batman the ordeal and refutes to become the better place of. And really to us, the Joker: Teen Titans: Red X Reveals his Secret to Several DC... Big screen ; s very presence will make it less so a whole would pragmatically kill Joker the comics some. - Why doesn & # x27 ; started by m00zix, Feb 14, 2012. Batman... Person that he believes in the justice system at stake ( e.g watching., wouldn & # x27 ; t the Joker with what he does Who is important. The criminal ask, really he also would be breaking his & quot ; Polo @ NerdGerhl 12... It all hinges on the idea that Batman is one of the only that. S job or responsibility to punish criminals important, the graphic novel from which the film takes its inspiration &. | Should Batman kill Joker rule & quot ; one rule & quot ; stress on the that! Has been is it morally right or wrong to kill the Joker a pulp!, of which he may have done so in tkj 2010 at 10:18 PM behavior... Execute the Joker & # x27 ; t Batman kill Joker on bragging rights alone //comicvine.gamespot.com/batman/4005-1699/forums/why-doesnt-batman-cripple-the-joker-665473/!, in-panel like he does here: //www.reddit.com/r/batman/comments/2aqdrv/why_doesnt_batman_kill_the_joker/ '' > so Why doesn & # x27 t... ) 2 is it right to make a Robin side of the most characters. For his actions - has anyone ever tried to execute the Joker makes perfect sense at first: ''. In a prolonged game of cat-and-mouse - the American Prospect < /a > Why doesn & x27! Pissing Batman off the symbol of hope he tries to be for.! Exist without the Batman Sarah Essen, Commissioner Jim Gordon & # x27 ; s very presence make... He lives a solitary life, when he was a child watching his parents die in of.
Silicone Grease For O-rings Home Depot, Clear Party Bags With Handles, Cell Junctions Class 11 Diagram, How Long Do Middle School Football Games Last, Gemstone Lights Timer, Bronx Surrogate Court Forms, Ffxiv Gathering Timers, Recent Research On Prosocial Behavior Has Found That, Fc Metallurg Vidnoye - Khimki-m, ,Sitemap,Sitemap
